What Does Diversity Mean on Your Board?
By Donna Hamlin, Ph.D., Advantary Partner
Diversity has several dimensions, so it matters in which way your board is “diverse.” It can mean distinctions in the composition of directors by gender, race, age, skills, expertise, geographic and cultural experience, and – from our research – most significantly, diversity of thought. By this, we mean robust diversity in members' orientations to problem-solving.
The focus on regulatory requirements for diversity on corporate boards continues globally, despite select legal challenges on the move from principle-based push to policy-based mandates.
While most attention has been on gender, it is taking a “twist.” For example, Malaysia adopted reforms in 2017 requiring large companies to have at least 30% of native Malaysian women directors on their boards and to disclose their diversity policy, target, and measures to reach the targets. Large companies were defined as those on the FTSA Bursa Malaysia Top 100 Index or with a market capitalization of RM2 billion or more at the start of the company’s financial year. While no sanctions were prescribed for failure to comply, the Prime Minister warned that companies failing to comply by 2018 would be named and shamed. The Securities Commission (SC) published statistics showing these reforms have increased women's representation in the top Malaysian publicly listed company from 16.6 percent to 23.7 in two years. Compared to other countries, female representation in Malaysia is higher than in Singapore and Hong Kong but lower than in the UK and Australia.
In the U.S., the latest news comes from Hawaii, with a law under consideration that would require all companies located in the state to have a minimum of one female or non-binary director and one male or non-binary director before the end of 2023. Further, the requirement will expand to three of each category by 2025. The consideration here is about the “balance” of men and women. Violations of this law would include fines of $5000 a year and $500 for failure to submit the required diversity reporting to the state. In comparison, the legal mandates in California for board seats for women and underrepresented communities have been stymied after court rulings struck them down. The SEC is also challenged with litigation related to similar rules for companies listed on NASDAQ.
The research on the positive impact of diversity on boards both expands and shows it comes from more than just gender balance. Diversity of thought -- orientations and problem–solving styles–– correlate highly with ideation, quality decision-making, and corporate performance metrics.
We research five key styles to ensure boards have diversity of thought at the table.
Craft the Best Diversity for Your Board
It’s time for boards to reframe their vision for board composition.
Step One: Understand the potential of diversity.
Step Two: Clarify the direction and needs to reach organizational goals.
Step Three: Define what mix of diversity will optimize board performance.
Step Four: Describe the combination of factors that describe the ideal candidates for your specific board situation: What robust mix of skills, experience, perspectives, and thinking styles will create the most high-performing board?
Step Five: Understand how competent your board and executive team is in inclusion. It is one thing to create diversity. It can be another thing if a group needs to be more skilled in appreciating it. Inclusion is a skill. If needed, train and build this skill.
Step Six: Collaborate and align the board and executive management on a culture that understands the value of diversity and the leverage it provides for long-term success.
Refinement in board composition is both growing and becoming more thoughtful. We provide board committees with assessment and profiling to help craft the ideal composition. Reach out if you seek support.
What Does Diversity Mean on Your Board?
By Donna Hamlin, Ph.D., Advantary Partner
{"nodes":[{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"foo","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.38"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"rbns","nodes":[],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"f5thc","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Advantary LLC","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.38"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"3212b","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Advantary Services Group","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.38"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"5ijad","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"July 14, 2022","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.38"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"7k76i","nodes":[],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"bp25c","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"\n","decorations":[]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Advantary Services Group Announces Expansion of Executive Capital Practice","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"CENTER","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"1g0ah","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Led By Kristin Speer, Veteran HR and Recruiting Expert","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"CENTER","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"3642n","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Westwood & Wilshire’s Kristin Speer to Provide Retained ","decorations":[{"type":"ITALIC","italicData":true}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"CENTER","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"5kfge","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Search and Human Capital Strategic Advice","decorations":[{"type":"ITALIC","italicData":true}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"CENTER","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"95t73","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":" ","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"CENTER","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"6v1sj","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"SAN FRANCISCO, August 3, 2022","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":" -- ","decorations":[]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Advantary","decorations":[{"type":"LINK","linkData":{"link":{"target":"SELF","url":"https://www.advantary.co/"}}}]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":" Services Group (ASG), a division of Advantary LLC, a private equity investor and provider of bespoke advisory services to select non-portfolio clients, announced today that Kristin Speer, managing director of ","decorations":[]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Westwood & Wilshire","decorations":[{"type":"LINK","linkData":{"link":{"target":"SELF","url":"http://westwoodwilshire.com/"}}},{"type":"UNDERLINE","underlineData":true}]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":", has joined as a partner. Speer will lead Advantary’s new Executive Capital practice and brings all of Westwood and Wilshire’s team of 35 recruiting and consulting professionals to Advantary in a unique partnership.","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"agste","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":" ","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"ffs4s","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Advantary’s Executive Capital practice addresses the large and growing demand for HR advisory and recruiting services fueled by the ongoing global transformation of the modern workplace. ","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"bu1b1","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":" ","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"7k0bm","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"With Speer’s expertise and experience working with companies such as [","decorations":[]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Super","decorations":[{"type":"LINK","linkData":{"link":{"target":"SELF","url":"http://www.hellosuper.com/"}}},{"type":"UNDERLINE","underlineData":true}]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"], [","decorations":[]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Movano","decorations":[{"type":"LINK","linkData":{"link":{"target":"SELF","url":"http://www.movano.com/"}}},{"type":"UNDERLINE","underlineData":true}]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"], and [","decorations":[]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Vaxart","decorations":[{"type":"LINK","linkData":{"link":{"target":"SELF","url":"http://www.vaxart.com/"}}},{"type":"UNDERLINE","underlineData":true}]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"], Advantary will offer Executive Capital advisory for optimal company performance, including leadership team guidance, executive search, company culture and cohesion, and diversity, equity and inclusion (DE&I). Advantary’s Executive Capital practice provides on-demand confidential experts to give CEOs objective advice on a broad range of organizational issues.","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"8fgg6","nodes":[],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"93nmq","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"As a partner in Advantary’s Executive Capital practice, Speer leads the retained CxO and VP searches, focused on placing executives across all operational functions to scale technology companies. In addition, Speer is managing partner at Westwood & Wilshire, an executive search firm in Silicon Valley. She co-founded AccelPeople, Westwood & Wilshire’s Center for Organizational Excellence, and is also a board member of the HR Strategy Forum.","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"5fntm","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":" ","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"5duev","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"“I am excited to join Advantary’s team with the goal of providing leadership teams and CEOs with a strategic CHRO-Level HR advisor for ongoing advice on organizational issues,” said Speer.","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"36vva","nodes":[],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"c5q2b","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"“Kristin Speer’s experience with technology CEOs and executive teams makes her the ideal partner for our new Executive Capital practice,” said Stephen Kuhn, CEO of Advantary. “We launched the Executive Capital practice as a result of direct conversations with many hundreds of CEOs globally since February 2020. Kris is the obvious industry veteran to lead it. We are extremely fortunate to have her.”","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"4hj3b","nodes":[],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"1r4op","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"About Advantary Capital Partners and Advantary Services Group","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"4eg28","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Advantary Capital Partners (ACP) invests in traditional buyouts, management buyouts and rollups where the firm believes its expertise can drive transformation that unlocks the potential of great companies. ACP is committed to a long-term investment approach. Advantary Services Group (ASG) is ACP’s team of extraordinary operating partners and advisors who have deep operating, execution, turnaround and investment experience, leveraging these skills for its portfolio and select non-portfolio companies.","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"efh25","nodes":[],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"3095l","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"About Westwood & Wilshire","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"3bhfl","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Westwood & Wilshire is a retained executive-search firm delivering premier talent in life sciences, healthcare, and advanced technology to the world’s most innovative companies. Our specialty is bringing top-flight, executive leaders to growing venture-backed companies looking for the best people to fill their C-Suite hires. Clients around the globe work with Westwood & Wilshire recruiters, who are based in Los Angeles, Silicon Valley, Scottsdale, and the New York metro area. Contact information can be found at ","decorations":[]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"https://westwoodwilshire.com/contact-us","decorations":[{"type":"LINK","linkData":{"link":{"target":"SELF","url":"https://westwoodwilshire.com/contact-us"}}},{"type":"UNDERLINE","underlineData":true}]}},{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":".","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"7qk1s","nodes":[],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"67ub2","nodes":[],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"5orlm","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"###","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"CENTER","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"i75m","nodes":[],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"6ajli","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"For More Information:","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"5hrge","nodes":[],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"6407k","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Kristin Speer","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"8d8nt","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Partner","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"5j3k5","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Advantary LLC","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"1liu3","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"650-245-331","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"3qn0","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":" ","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"7udq6","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Betsy Klein","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"c2u6h","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Director of Marketing","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"ehp8q","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"Advantary LLC","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"esi5f","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":"714-478-0353","decorations":[]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"7qc2i","nodes":[{"type":"TEXT","id":"","nodes":[],"textData":{"text":" ","decorations":[{"type":"BOLD","fontWeightValue":700}]}}],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO","lineHeight":"1.2"},"indentation":0}},{"type":"PARAGRAPH","id":"ajles","nodes":[],"paragraphData":{"textStyle":{"textAlignment":"AUTO"},"indentation":0}}],"metadata":{"version":1,"createdTimestamp":"2022-08-03T22:50:15.926Z","updatedTimestamp":"2022-08-03T22:50:15.926Z","id":"899610c7-f121-415b-907e-6e408597e801"},"documentStyle":{}}